Menu of The Eatery in Catoosa, Oklahoma, USA

Menu Overview

Located at 77 W Cherokee St in Catoosa, Oklahoma, The Eatery offers a buffet experience that artfully combines variety with quality. As a buffet restaurant, it presents an impressive lineup of dishes, each crafted with care and a distinct attention to flavor. The menu stands out with its signature items such as the Grilled Prime Rib PB Delight and the indulgent Turtle Cheesecake, both of which reflect the kitchen’s commitment to delivering memorable taste experiences.

The Eatery's buffet is a treasure trove of choices. From the smoky richness of the Hickory Smoked Bacon and the crispy texture of Coconut Shrimp to the fresh, peppery notes in the Baby Arugula Salad and the bold, smoky layers of the Blackened Salmon, the menu balances indulgence with lighter options seamlessly. Specialty dishes like the Eatery's Bouillabaisse and the elegantly presented Poached Eggs Caprese provide depth and variety, appealing to varied palates and dietary preferences.

One cannot discuss The Eatery without mentioning the outstanding seafood selections. The Fried Fantail Shrimp and Sautéed Shrimp Scampi arrive cooked to perfection—crispy but tender, fragrant with garlic and herbs, spotlighting freshness and skillful preparation. The Bacon Wrapped Roasted Pork Loin offers a rich, savory counterbalance, while classics like the Classic Chicken Cordon Bleu retain their comforting appeal.

Of particular note is the dessert experience, crowned by the famed Turtle Cheesecake. Its velvety texture and harmonious blend of chocolate, caramel, and nuts provide a sweet finale to the meal. Complementing this is the fresh juice selection that refreshes the palate across courses.

The atmosphere and service form an essential part of the experience here. Feedback consistently highlights the attentive, proactive staff who ensure drinks are always filled and plates swiftly cleared, creating an inviting and seamless dining rhythm. The Eatery’s team even takes special care with dietary restrictions, exemplified by the chef personally guiding patrons through allergen-sensitive choices.

From customer insights, the buffet shines as a reliable destination for both families and food enthusiasts, praised for its freshness, breadth, and consistent quality. The mashed potatoes, frequently lauded as "buttery clouds," elevate comfort food to an art form. Even amid minor dessert missteps, such as the less impressive crème brûlée and pumpkin pie, the upbeat energy and overall palate satisfaction remain strong.

All told, The Eatery embodies what a modern buffet should aspire to: abundant, well-executed dishes combined with faultless service and an atmosphere both warm and lively. For anyone near Catoosa or Tulsa, it’s a destination worth savoring—bring your appetite and a sense of culinary adventure.